262
LivaClean vs. Mighty Patch: 272 patches or 26?
Both are hydrocolloid pimple patches. Here's what each box gets you, from price per patch to sizes, and where Mighty Patch comes out ahead.
4.6 from 4,223 ratings on
| Mighty Patch Variety | LivaClean 272 | |
|---|---|---|
| Patches | 26 | 272 |
| Per patch | 53¢ | 4¢ |
| Sizes | 2 | 10 |
$9.49 with Subscribe & Save or $9.99 one-time
Shop now on Amazon
Free fast shipping
Try it risk-free. Not happy? We'll send a replacement or give you a refund.
Mighty Patch made pimple patches famous. So what's different?
Mighty Patch is the pimple patch most people know. Mighty Patch Original has 185,175 ratings on Amazon, and Hero Cosmetics helped turn a small hydrocolloid dot into a bathroom-cabinet staple.1
So this isn't about whether pimple patches work. It's about what you get in the box: how many patches, in which sizes, and what each one costs.
We compared the LivaClean 272 variety pack with the Mighty Patch Variety Pack, the closest Hero box, using Amazon.com listings from September 17, 2026. We added Mighty Patch Original, the one most people have tried. Where Mighty Patch comes out ahead, we say so.
Quick orientation
 Mighty Patch Variety |
 LivaClean 272 |
|
|---|---|---|
| In the box | 12 Original, 12 Invisible+ and 2 Surface patches2 | 120 thin day circles, 120 thick night circles, 16 large strips and 16 large squares3 |
| What it's made of | drug-free hydrocolloid2 | hydrocolloid with salicylic acid, tea tree oil and calendula oil4 |
| Best for | Someone who wants a household-name brand and uses a patch now and then | Anyone who goes through patches every week, gets breakouts in more than one size, or shares a box |
LivaClean vs. Mighty Patch, side by side
Amazon.com one-time prices and listing details from September 17, 2026.
| Mighty Patch Variety |
LivaClean 272 |
The LivaClean difference | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Patches in the box | 2724 |
10 times the patches in one box2,4 | |
| Price per patch | 93% less per patch2,4 | ||
| Price per patch vs. Mighty Patch Original | 89% less per patch than the Original1,4 | ||
| Patch sizes | A size for a single dot, a row along the jaw or a cluster | ||
| Large patches for clusters | 22Surface patches |
Cover a chin or jawline cluster with one patch instead of a row of dots | |
| Day and night patches | Yes: Original dots for night, Invisible+ dots for day2 |
Yes: 120 thin day circles and 120 thick night circles |
Both boxes cover day and night. LivaClean has more of each, in 4 sizes. |
| What's in the patch | drug-free hydrocolloid2 |
hydrocolloid with salicylic acid, tea tree oil and calendula oil4 |
Pick plain hydrocolloid, or hydrocolloid with added salicylic acid |
| Skin testing | Yes: allergy tested2 |
Yes: Clinically proven gentle on skin: 101 adults, 0 reactions6 |
Both brands test on skin |
| No added scent | Yes: Original: formulated without added fragrance7 |
No: Contains tea tree oil, and some reviewers notice the scent |
Mighty Patch wins if you want no scent at all |
| Where to buy | Amazon, the Hero Cosmetics site and retail stores7 |
Amazon, with Prime shipping |
Mighty Patch wins if you want one from a store today |
Compared: LivaClean 272 variety pack (B0CB1KF6VT), Mighty Patch Variety Pack 26 ct (B085P3TYPS) and Mighty Patch Original 36 ct (B074PVTPBW). Price per patch is the one-time Amazon price divided by the patch count, rounded in Mighty Patch's favor. Patch sizes differ between brands. Prices as of September 17, 2026 and may change.
Shop now on Amazon
Free fast shipping + risk-free replacement or refund
Ten sizes, not two
The Mighty Patch Variety Pack mixes 12 Original, 12 Invisible+ and 2 Surface patches. That's 12 mm dots plus two large 60 x 25 mm patches.1,2,5
The LivaClean box has 120 thin day circles, 120 thick night circles, 16 large strips and 16 large squares. Circles come in 8, 10, 12 and 14 mm, strips are 20 x 60 mm and squares are 45 x 45 mm, and you can trim a square to any shape.3
| Mighty Patch Variety |
LivaClean 272 |
|
|---|---|---|
| Patch sizes | ||
| Large patches for clusters | 22Surface patches |
Net: If breakouts only ever show up one small dot at a time, a 12 mm dot does the job. If they come as a row along the jaw or a cluster, the bigger patches earn their place.
The per-patch math
Mighty Patch Variety costs $13.97 for 26 patches on Amazon, about 53¢ a patch. The LivaClean 272 pack costs $9.99 for 272, about 4¢ a patch.2,4
That's 93% less per patch and $3.98 less for the box. Against Mighty Patch Original ($12.99 for 36), it's 89% less per patch.1,2,4
At these prices, $10 worth of patches is 272 LivaClean patches or 18 Mighty Patch Variety patches. With Subscribe & Save, the boxes are $9.49 and $12.57.2,4
| Mighty Patch Variety |
LivaClean 272 |
|
|---|---|---|
| Price per patch | ||
| Price per patch vs. Mighty Patch Original |
Net: Same hydrocolloid idea, a much lower cost per patch. If you use more than a few patches a month, the gap adds up.
Shop now on Amazon
Free fast shipping + risk-free replacement or refund
Day, night and the big ones
Both boxes mix day and night patches. Hero pairs Original dots for night, Invisible+ dots for day. LivaClean has 120 thin day circles and 120 thick night circles, 4 sizes each.2
LivaClean's thin circles are for daytime and the thick ones are for overnight, and every size comes in both.
| Mighty Patch Variety |
LivaClean 272 |
|
|---|---|---|
| Day and night patches | Yes: Original dots for night, Invisible+ dots for day2 |
Yes: 120 thin day circles and 120 thick night circles |
Net: Both cover day and night. LivaClean gives you more of each, in more sizes.
From people who've used both
Verified Amazon reviews of the LivaClean 272 variety pack that mention Hero, Mighty Patch or name brands.
-
SUCH a deal!
Reviewed in the United States on September 11, 2026
Verified Purchase
...considerably cheaper for way more of them. Won't be going back to HERO, other than for their micro-spike patches which I don't need nearly as often.
-
Great value and effective
Reviewed in the United States on March 18, 2025
Verified Purchase
The variety of sizes is great, and I feel like I get more for my money compared to Hero patches or other brands I've used.
-
Work well
Reviewed in the United States on April 8, 2026
Verified Purchase
I like the variety of sizes and thickness. The thinner circles can be worn during the day as they're barely noticeable, and the thick circles are great to extract more pimple juice overnight. I have these on auto delivery because they're the best value for price I've seen.
-
Amazing!
Reviewed in the United States on March 13, 2026
Verified Purchase
I will continue to buy these if and when I run out since it comes with SO many! But very good quality and cheaper than name brands at the store.
Shop now on Amazon
Free fast shipping + risk-free replacement or refund
Where Mighty Patch wins
Hero Cosmetics earned its name. Here's where Mighty Patch is the better pick.
The name most people know
Mighty Patch Original has 185,175 ratings and 100K+ bought in the past month on Amazon.1
No added fragrance
Hero says Mighty Patch Original is formulated without added fragrance. LivaClean patches have tea tree oil, and some reviewers notice the scent.7
Plain hydrocolloid
Mighty Patch is drug-free hydrocolloid with no salicylic acid, so it's the pick if you'd rather skip added ingredients.2
Sold in stores
Hero lists retail stores on its site7, so you can pick one up today instead of waiting for delivery.
“...the scent is strong which I don't mind but it could be off-putting...”
Michael Crouchley, 4-star verified review of LivaClean, Jul 2024
The verdict: pick by how you break out
Mighty Patch is a good patch from a brand that earned its name. The difference is the box: 26 patches in 2 sizes, or 272 patches in 10 sizes for $3.98 less.2,4,5
Pick Mighty Patch if
- Yes:You only need a patch now and then
- Yes:You'd rather skip salicylic acid and tea tree oil
- Yes:You want to buy one in a store today
272 patches, every size, risk-free
One box covers day spots, overnight whiteheads and clusters for about 4¢ a patch. Not happy? We'll send a replacement or give you a refund.4
$9.49with Subscribe & Save, or $9.99 one-time. 500 million+ patches sold on Amazon.
Shop now on Amazon
Free fast shipping + risk-free replacement or refund
Try it risk-free
If the patches don't work for you, contact us through your Amazon order and we'll send a replacement or give you a refund.
Questions, answered
Is there a cheaper alternative to Mighty Patch?
Yes. The LivaClean 272 variety pack is a hydrocolloid pimple patch box with 272 patches in 10 sizes for $9.99 on Amazon, about 4¢ a patch. Mighty Patch Variety is 53¢ a patch and Mighty Patch Original is 36¢. The difference: LivaClean adds salicylic acid, tea tree oil and calendula oil, while Mighty Patch is plain hydrocolloid.1,2,4
Is LivaClean as good as Mighty Patch?
Both are hydrocolloid pimple patches that absorb fluid from surface whiteheads, and we don't make a head-to-head results claim. The difference is the box: 272 patches in 10 sizes with salicylic acid, tea tree oil and calendula oil, or 26 drug-free patches.2,4
Why is LivaClean so much cheaper per patch?
The box is bigger and the price is lower: 272 patches for $9.99 one-time on Amazon. That's 4¢ a patch, against 53¢ for Mighty Patch Variety and 36¢ for Mighty Patch Original.1,2,4
Does LivaClean have salicylic acid?
Yes. LivaClean patches are hydrocolloid with salicylic acid, tea tree oil and calendula oil. Mighty Patch Original and the Variety Pack are drug-free hydrocolloid. If you want plain hydrocolloid, Mighty Patch is the better fit.2
Which is better for big breakouts or clusters?
The LivaClean box has 32 large patches: strips (20 x 60 mm) and squares (45 x 45 mm) you can trim. Mighty Patch Variety has 2 Surface patches (60 x 25 mm).2,3,5
Are LivaClean patches gentle on sensitive skin?
In a 6-week repeat insult patch test, 101 adults, 0 reactions. They contain tea tree oil, so if you're new to patches, try one a day for three days first.6
What if they don't work for me?
Try it risk-free. Contact us through your Amazon order and we'll send a replacement or give you a refund.
Works cited
- Mighty Patch Hero Cosmetics Original Nighttime Acne Pimple Patches, 36 Ct. Amazon.com. Accessed September 17, 2026. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B074PVTPBW
- Mighty Patch Hero Cosmetics Variety Pack of Acne Pimple Patches, 26 Ct. Amazon.com. Accessed September 17, 2026. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B085P3TYPS
- LivaClean 272 variety pack contents and patch sizes. LivaClean. Accessed September 17, 2026. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0CB1KF6VT
- 272 CT Large Pimple Patches for Face, 10 Sizes Variety Pack. Amazon.com. Accessed September 17, 2026. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0CB1KF6VT
- Mighty Patch Variety Pack. Hero Cosmetics. Accessed September 17, 2026. https://www.herocosmetics.us/products/mighty-patch-variety-pack
- Repeat insult patch test PGURIP1T on LivaClean hydrocolloid pimple patches (101 adults completed, 0 adverse reactions). Princeton Consumer Research Corp., study report. Accessed May 14, 2024.
- Mighty Patch Original. Hero Cosmetics. Accessed September 17, 2026. https://www.herocosmetics.us/products/mighty-patch-original
Mighty Patch is a trademark of Hero Cosmetics. LivaClean is not affiliated with Hero Cosmetics or Church & Dwight Co., Inc.
Compared: LivaClean 272 variety pack (B0CB1KF6VT), Mighty Patch Variety Pack 26 ct (B085P3TYPS) and Mighty Patch Original 36 ct (B074PVTPBW). Price per patch is the one-time Amazon price divided by the patch count, rounded in Mighty Patch's favor. Patch sizes differ between brands. One-time purchase prices on Amazon.com as of September 17, 2026 and may change. Product details come from each brand's Amazon listing and website on that date.
Reviews are verbatim from verified Amazon purchases of the LivaClean 272 variety pack. Individual results may vary.